Rashmee Roshan Lall is a regular columnist for The Arab Weekly. She blogs at www.rashmee.com and is on Twitter @rashmeerl

  • Recep the Resolute, Turkey’s new sultan , On: Sun, 23 Apr 2017

  • Europe\'s extremism problem is essentially homegrown, On: Sun, 16 Apr 2017

  • Trump’s initial reaction to Syria’s suffering says a lot , On: Sun, 09 Apr 2017

  • In Europe, extremism is essentially a homegrown problem , On: Sun, 02 Apr 2017

  • Banning electronic devices: Security or economic protectionism?, On: Sun, 26 Mar 2017

  • Saudi King Salman, the Magnificent , On: Sun, 19 Mar 2017

  • Vogue Arabia adds perspective on women’s veil, On: Sun, 12 Mar 2017

  • Donald Trump’s America wants to make war on peace , On: Sun, 05 Mar 2017

  • Is there a Trump in the house to speak up for Muslims? , On: Sun, 26 Feb 2017

  • Dealing with fake news , On: Sun, 19 Feb 2017

  • Trump and Al-Farabi’s ‘virtuous city’ , On: Sun, 12 Feb 2017

  • The message Trump sends to the Muslim world , On: Sun, 05 Feb 2017

  • The ‘alternative facts’ of Trump’s White House , On: Sun, 29 Jan 2017

  • Will Britain sell out the Palestinians again?, On: Sun, 22 Jan 2017

  • Jared Kushner has wasta, On: Sun, 15 Jan 2017

  • The Obama administration’s last-minute stand with the Palestinians, On: Sun, 08 Jan 2017

  • The US can no longer pretend to be an honest broker, On: Sun, 25 Dec 2016

  • The thin line between free speech and hate speech , On: Sun, 18 Dec 2016

  • When a European country takes an honest view of Muslims in its midst, On: Sun, 11 Dec 2016

  • What would Trump do after a lone-wolf attack?, On: Sun, 04 Dec 2016

  • US risks losing moral authority on climate change, On: Sun, 20 Nov 2016

  • Unpredictable times ahead after US election , On: Sun, 13 Nov 2016

  • Why Trump has fans in the Middle East , On: Sun, 06 Nov 2016

  • US Mormons stand shoulder to shoulder with Muslims, On: Sun, 30 Oct 2016

  • The unfulfilled Dabiq prophecy an omen for ISIS, On: Sun, 23 Oct 2016

  • Britain is turning sharply right , On: Sun, 16 Oct 2016

  • Time for MENA Americans to stand up and be counted , On: Sun, 09 Oct 2016

  • Can air links prevent conflict? , On: Sun, 02 Oct 2016

  • Is American leadership of the world irreversibly in decline?, On: Sun, 02 Oct 2016

  • Europeans need candour in handling refugee issue, On: Sun, 25 Sep 2016

  • ‘What is Aleppo’: A nothing on grand scale of American ignorance , On: Sun, 18 Sep 2016

  • A ‘death stare war’ in Hangzhou turned into the Syria deal, On: Sun, 11 Sep 2016

  • Dual citizenship under attack in Europe, On: Sun, 04 Sep 2016

  • The politically shrewd option for French and German Muslims , On: Sun, 28 Aug 2016

  • Burqini battles are a pointless skirmish, On: Sun, 21 Aug 2016

  • Refugee Olympic Team helps debunk myths , On: Sun, 14 Aug 2016

  • The implications of the Trump v Khan episode, On: Sun, 07 Aug 2016

  • The heart of Europe bleeds. What can it do? , On: Sun, 31 Jul 2016

  • The West should be addressing grievances behind attacks, On: Sun, 24 Jul 2016

  • Recep the Resolute, Turkey’s new sultan

    Authoritarianisation aims to project the glowing façade of democracy while preventing any examination of its hollowed-out interior.


    2017/04/23 Issue: 103 Page: 2



    Orhan Pamuk, Nobel literature laureate and one of the greatest contempo­rary chroniclers of Istanbul, once asked if the city’s takeover by the Muslim Ottomans represented conquest or decline. Opinions on the historical events of 1453 are divided, Pamuk mused, by whether you’re standing in the east or the west of the city. In western Istanbul, the Ottoman victory is seen as the fall of Constantinople. For easterners, it is always the conquest of Istanbul.

    Something similar, if on a larger national stage, may be said of Tur­key after President Recep Tayyip Erdogan’s narrow win in the April 16 referendum. The proposed constitutional changes will swell the president’s powers to almost grotesque proportions.

    Is it a conquest over Turkey’s coup-prone army or a manifesta­tion of the country’s democratic decline?

    Was the referendum’s 51.4% “yes” result a test of wills between rural and urban Turkey? Three of its largest cities — Istanbul, Ankara and Izmir — voted against Erdogan’s proposed changes but the conservative heartland was in favour.

    Was it a struggle between simple pious folks and sophisticated secu­lar ones?

    Was it a contest between a dying old order and a new one struggling to be born?

    The oft-expressed fear is that Erdogan’s constitutional changes will allow him to style himself as a neo-Ottoman sultan, brooking no dissent or questioning and seeking to rule by diktat and fiat, the secu­lar fatwa of elected autocrats.

    The unstated fear is that the secular fatwa will become the template for a region in which democratisation is either patchy or ignored outright. Roiled by uprisings that were once collec­tively and hopefully dubbed the “Arab spring,” governments in the Middle East and North Africa have been treading softly for the past five years, without much enthusi­asm for more inclusive politics or visionary reform. Could Erdogan’s Turkey serve as a role model?

    Once upon a time, Erdogan seemed to think it could. He pre­sented Turkey as the ideal model for the region because it offered a unique blend of Western-style democracy and Islam. He declared as much in September 2012 at his Justice and Development Party’s annual conference in Ankara. Er­dogan told the party and a hundred foreign guests, including Egypt’s then president, Muhammad Morsi, that Turkey had “become a role model for Muslim countries.”

    Just ten months later, Morsi, Egypt’s first democratically elected president, was gone, having been ousted by the army.

    Erdogan appears to have learnt some of the right lessons from Morsi’s downfall. First, that it is important to curb the powers of the military, especially in Turkey, which has had four successful coups since 1960, one coup con­spiracy and last year’s failed at­tempt. To the extent that Erdogan’s constitutional changes make a military coup less likely, they actu­ally strengthen democracy.

    However, by allowing Turkey’s powerful new executive presidency to reign supreme instead, Erdogan may have created Version 2.0 of the Turkish model he once praised. This recommends having elections to consolidate power as well as to undermine institutional checks and balances.

    Erdogan, of course, cannot pat­ent this idea. It is old (remember Hugo Chavez in Venezuela?) and it is well-worn (Vladimir Putin has been using it to devastating effect in Russia) but it is an interesting innovation for the region because it blends the process of democracy — elections, a genuine contest — with the undermining of democratic norms, such as checks and balanc­es, a free press and healthy political debate.

    This phenomenon has a long name — authoritarianisation — but it has a brutally short agenda.

    It aims to project the glowing fa­çade of democracy while prevent­ing examination of its hollowed-out interior.

    It is a seductive idea. The tragedy would be if Recep the Resolute, Turkey’s new sultan, manages not only to dismantle democracy at home but to hawk this bill of goods around the region.

    Editors' Picks

    The Arab Weekly Newspaper reaches Western & Arabic audience that are influential as well as being affluent.

    From Europe to the Middle East,and North America, The Arab Weekly talks to opinion formers and influential figures, providing insight and comment on national, international and regional news through the focus of Arabic countries and community.

    Published by Al Arab Publishing House

    Publisher and Group Executive Editor: Haitham El-Zobaidi, PhD

    Editor-in-Chief: Oussama Romdhani

    Deputy Editor-in-Chief: Dalal Saoud

    Senior Editor: John Hendel

    Chief Copy Editors: Jonathan Hemming and Richard Pretorius

    Analysis Section Editor: Ed Blanche

    Opinion Section Editor: Claude Salhani

    East/West Section Editor: Mark Habeeb

    Levant Section Editor: Jamal J. Halaby

    Gulf Section Editor: Mohammed Alkhereiji

    Society and Travel Sections Editor: Samar Kadi

    Senior Correspondents:

    Mahmud el-Shafey (London)

    Lamine Ghanmi (Tunis)

    Correspondents

    Saad Guerraoui (Casablanca)

    Dunia El-Zobeidi (London)

    Roua Khlifi (Tunis)

    Rasha Elass - Thomas Seibert (Washington)

    Published by Al Arab Publishing House

    Contact editor at:editor@thearabweekly.com

    Subscription & Advertising: Ads@alarab.co.uk

    Tel 020 3667 7249

    Mohamed Al Mufti

    Marketing & Advertising Manager

    Tel (Main) +44 20 6702 3999

    Direct: +44 20 8742 9262

    www.alarab.co.uk

    Al Arab Publishing House

    Kensington Centre

    66 Hammersmith Road

    London W14 8UD, UK

    Tel: (+44) 20 7602 3999

    Fax: (+44) 20 7602 8778

    Follow Us
    © The Arab Weekly, All rights reserved