Germany’s backhanded compliment to Maghreb countries

Maghreb In-Betweeners are just stable enough — even if sometimes a hair’s breadth from a truly parlous state — to be denied special consideration accorded to Syrian refugees.

2016/05/22 Issue: 57 Page: 16

The Arab Weekly
Rashmee Roshan Lall

Tunisia, Algeria and Morocco have received a back­handed compliment from Germany, Europe’s most industrialised and populous country. All three are “safe countries of origin” for the purposes of determining their nationals’ claim to asylum, according to a draft law passed by the lower house of the German parliament.

In other words, Tunisians, Algerians and Moroccans enjoy safe enough conditions at home and must reconcile themselves to staying where they are. The three countries are neither a smash­ing success nor failure most foul. They are in-between.

The Maghreb In-Betweeners are just stable enough — even if sometimes a hair’s breadth from a truly parlous state — to be denied the special consideration accorded to Syrian refugees. Or to Iraqis with particularly piteous stories. Or to Afghans, though even they cannot automatically expect to get asylum in Europe any more.

The German law does not, of course, rule out sui generis appeals for refuge from individuals who face persecution of some sort in Tunis, Algiers and Rabat. Overall, however, the three countries are in-between the best of times and worst of times.

How else to read German Inte­rior Minister Thomas de Maiziere’s remarkable admission that Algeria and Morocco are not democratic states, that human rights lapses may occur in all three Maghreb countries but that they are still safe enough for administrative reclassification?

In and of itself, de Maiziere’s statement contains nothing new and neither does the proposed law. The minister said pretty much the same thing in February when he visited the Maghreb. A mix of pleas, penalties and rewards was employed to persuade all three to take back failed asylum seekers. De Maiziere indicated that all three saw themselves as safe.

Apparently, German authorities had been working to that assump­tion anyway, right through 2015. According to data from its Federal Office for Migration and Refugees (BAMF), 2.1% of the approximately 26,000 people from the Maghreb who arrived in Germany last year were given asylum. That figure dropped to 0.7% in the first quar­ter of 2016.

Soon enough, the numbers will shrink further because fewer arrivals are being recorded from the Maghreb Three. According to BAMF data, more than 3,300 asy­lum seekers from Tunisia, Algeria and Morocco were registered in Germany in January. By March, it had dropped to 480.

This is thought to be the result of the public discussions that foreshadowed Germany’s plans to classify the Maghreb Three as safe countries. Now that it has all but happened — the upper house of parliament is still to approve the law — only the foolhardy can be expected seriously to try for asylum in Germany.

This is an act of administra­tive triage for a Germany that feels overwhelmed by more than 1 million asylum seekers in 2015. Syrians’ need is deemed greater than that of Tunisians, Algerians and Moroccans. Germany, so the reasoning goes, cannot take in everyone with a hard luck story.

Fair enough. The three Maghreb In-Betweeners are not being torn apart on sectarian lines such as in Iraq. They are not basket cases as Libya is. Their nationals do not face the bloodletting and the bombs driving the Syrians to seek sanctuary in foreign lands. There is a certain logic in weeding out asylum seekers from countries that are a whole lot more settled than Syria. Europe cannot take the huddled masses from around the world and, right now, its focus remains, as it must, on Syrians.

The Maghreb in-Betweeners face different challenges, howev­er, and none so much as Tunisia. Five years after the uprising that swept away the old order, jobless­ness and inflation remain high, economic growth low and hope for the future is in short supply.

In December, a European Com­mission paper noted that five years after the “Arab spring”, “the performance of the Maghreb economies remains much weaker than in the previous ten years… All these countries, and in particu­lar Tunisia, are very dependent on the EU economy so that the persistent weakness in the latter has continued to limit their capac­ity to recover.”

Tunisia needs help — trade and economic cooperation agreements with Europe would mean con­tracts, jobs and foreign exchange — and perhaps, Europe could consider a plan that allows limited econom­ic migration for hard-to-fill jobs from countries such as Tunisia. The remittances sent home by workers would help Tunisia, as would the broader experience they gain.

This would make Europe a more realisable opportunity for dream­ers everywhere and reduce the impulse to seek asylum. It would be in Europe’s interest to help build a stable Tunisia, the only secular democracy born of the “Arab spring”.

Rashmee Roshan Lall is a regular columnist for The Arab Weekly. She blogs at and is on Twitter @rashmeerl

As Printed
Editors' Picks

The Arab Weekly Newspaper reaches Western & Arabic audience that are influential as well as being affluent.

From Europe to the Middle East,and North America, The Arab Weekly talks to opinion formers and influential figures, providing insight and comment on national, international and regional news through the focus of Arabic countries and community.

Published by Al Arab Publishing House

Publisher and Group Executive Editor: Haitham El-Zobaidi, PhD

Editor-in-Chief: Oussama Romdhani

Managing Editor: Iman Zayat

Deputy Managing Editor and Online Editor: Mamoon Alabbasi

Senior Editor: John Hendel

Chief Copy Editor: Richard Pretorius

Copy Editor: Stephen Quillen

Analysis Section Editor: Ed Blanche

East/West Section Editor: Mark Habeeb

Gulf Section Editor: Mohammed Alkhereiji

Society and Travel Sections Editor: Samar Kadi

Syria and Lebanon Sections Editor: Simon Speakman Cordall

Contributing Editor: Rashmee Roshan Lall

Senior Correspondents: Mahmud el-Shafey (London) & Lamine Ghanmi (Tunis)

Regular Columnists

Claude Salhani

Yavuz Baydar


Saad Guerraoui (Casablanca)

Dunia El-Zobaidi (London)

Roua Khlifi (Tunis)

Thomas Seibert (Washington)

Chief Designer: Marwen Hmedi


Ibrahim Ben Bechir

Hanen Jebali

Published by Al Arab Publishing House

Contact editor

Subscription & Advertising:

Tel 020 3667 7249

Mohamed Al Mufti

Marketing & Advertising Manager

Tel (Main) +44 20 6702 3999

Direct: +44 20 8742 9262

Al Arab Publishing House

Kensington Centre

177-179 Hammersmith Road

London W6 8BS , UK

Tel: (+44) 20 7602 3999

Fax: (+44) 20 7602 8778

Follow Us
© The Arab Weekly, All rights reserved