In the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, not all incitements are equal
Incitement against Palestinians is rife in Israeli society and among political and religious leaders.
A March 2015 picture shows a Palestinian woman walking down stairs in front of graffiti scrawled on the wall of a Palestinian home in al-Mughayir, east of Ramallah in the northern West Bank. (AP)
2016/11/13 Issue: 81 Page: 11
The Arab Weekly
London - Israel regularly accuses Palestinians of incitement, which it claims directly leads to violence against its security forces and, in some cases, Israeli civilians. This charge has gained prominence since the outbreak of violence in October in which individuals carried out attacks, mainly against Israeli armed forces at humiliating checkpoints. Commentators labelled the series of attacks the “knife intifada”.
Israel’s definition of what constitutes incitement is wide-ranging and includes Palestinians labelling those killed by Israeli forces “martyrs”, providing financial support to families of those killed or political prisoners, objecting to repeated incursions by Israeli extremists to al-Aqsa mosque, reporting Israel’s crimes to world bodies and even Palestinians reminiscing about returning to the towns and villages they came from before being driven out from 1948 onward.
More recently, Israel has turned its attention to social media. A “like” on a post or “praise” for an attack on Israeli security forces now constitutes incitement. The case of Palestinian astrophysicist Professor Imad Barghouti hit the headlines when he was sentenced to seven months in prison for “incitement” on Facebook. Evidence presented in support of the charge was the number of “likes” and “shares” his Facebook posts received.
Israeli authorities have exerted increasing pressure on social media platforms to stop “abetting Palestinian incitement”, which resulted in Facebook dispatching a delegation to Israel in September to meet with Israeli government officials. Israeli Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu noted that “the goal here is to improve cooperation against incitement, the incitement to terror and murder, on the social network”.
However, incitement against Palestinians is rife in Israeli society and among political and religious leaders. The chant of “death to the Arabs” is regularly heard from Israeli youths, this was particularly so during a Tel Aviv rally in support of Elor Azaria, the Israeli soldier who killed a gravely wounded Palestinian in Hebron in March.
Incitement on social media by Israelis is widespread. Take the example of Facebook user Arkadi Yakobov who wrote: “There is no shame in burning an Arab, it is a great mitzvah to burn Arabs”. Galit Elmaliach agreed and added “may all the Muhammads burn, amen”.
The news and opinion website +972 Magazine, which translated these from Hebrew, noted that “no one raised an eyebrow. Their lives went on without any interference by the Israeli justice system”.
This contrasts with the case of Palestinian Sami Da’is, who received five likes for one of the status posts mentioned in his indictment and nine likes in another. He was sentenced to eight months in prison.
Incitement against Palestinians by Israeli religious leaders is reported but generally goes unpunished. During Israel’s war on Gaza in 2014, extremist Israeli Rabbi Dov Lior, from the West Bank settlement of Kiryat Arba, issued a Halakhic ruling that sanctioned the killing of innocent civilians after being asked about the war in Gaza.
Incitement by Israeli politicians is also commonplace. Take Israeli Justice Minister Ayelet Shaked, who, when commenting on the attack on Gaza, said “the entire Palestinian people is the enemy”, adding “including its elderly and its women, its cities and its villages, its property and its infrastructure”. She justified the slaughter of Palestinian mothers who give birth to “little snakes”.
This was posted on her Facebook page in 2014 but in 2016 Shaked proudly announced that having been pressured by the Israeli government, Facebook had “complied with 95% of Israeli requests to delete content” but only of posts by Palestinians.
It seems that equality is such anathema to Israel that even when it comes to incitement, there is unequal treatment of Palestinians and Israelis. Likes for a post by a Palestinian can land you in jail but outright incitement by Israelis is tolerated.