Despite Egypt reforms, investors seen wary of returning
Key part of government’s efforts should be directed to improve business climate and reduce bureaucracy for small and medium enterprises.
Hoping for economic recovery. The third line of Cairo’s Metro, which is under construction. (AFP)
2017/03/12 Issue: 97 Page: 18
Cairo - Egypt is pursuing a raft of reforms to revive an economy weakened by years of turmoil but analysts say successfully wooing foreign investors will take time.
Since the 2011 uprising, the Arab world’s most populous country has suffered a slump in key tourism revenues, slowing economic growth and investment, double-digit inflation and falling foreign currency reserves.
In November, the International Monetary Fund (IMF) approved a $12 billion loan for Egypt after the government committed to reforms including floating the Egyptian pound, which subsequently plunged against the US dollar.
Authorities pledged a new investment law with tax incentives, a “one-stop-shop” to simplify investment procedures and a new bankruptcy law.
“Egypt’s economic recovery will come with a lag, until the government follows through on reform policies with a successful implementation,” said Hany Farahat, a senior economist at the Egyptian investment bank CI Capital.
Authorities have also introduced a value-added tax and cut fuel subsidies, moves the IMF said were required to fix government finances and boost investor confidence.
“Everyone is expecting 2017 to be a difficult year,” said Walid Allam, the chief financial officer in Egypt for Swiss elevator manufacturer Schindler, “but we expect that starting in 2018 there will be a bit of a revival. We are talking about a state, not a company that would take a decision and profit from it after a week or two.”
Foreign direct investment in Egypt fell from a peak of $13.2 billion in the fiscal year ending in June 2008 to $6.8 billion in the year ending in June 2016.
The tourism sector in particular is reeling from years of upheaval and a series of jihadist attacks, including the 2015 bombing of a Russian airliner carrying holidaymakers from the popular Red Sea resort of Sharm el-Sheikh.
Even before the tumultuous 2011 uprising that ousted longtime president Hosni Mubarak, Egypt’s economy was suffering from decades of structural problems and delayed reforms, said Ahmed Abdelnaby, a strategist at Mubasher Financial Services.
Investors will need time to see the government’s commitment to reforms if the business climate is overhauled, he said.
One of the challenges for Egypt is to diversify its sources of foreign currency, said political economist Amr Adly, non-resident scholar at the Carnegie Middle East Centre. This is particularly important as the main sources now — workers’ remittances, crude oil exports, the Suez Canal and tourism — “proved to be very volatile and cannot be depended on”, said Adly.
A key part of the government’s efforts should be directed to improve the business climate and reduce bureaucracy for small and medium enterprises and not just foreign investors, he said, adding that this would help boost local industries including agriculture and manufacturing.
Potential investors are keen to see additional structural reforms before committing to long-term investments, said Esraa Ahmed, an economist with Mubasher. She said more than half of the problems facing investors still need to be resolved.
“Investors have always suffered obstacles in procedures, corruption and bureaucracy. Reforming these issues will take some time,” she added.
The former chairman of the General Authority for Investment, Ziad Bahaa-Eldin, said fixing “genuine barriers” to investment would have a bigger effect than a new investment law.
These include “the state’s unclear economic and social vision, its competition with the private sector in all fields, the spread of corruption, and clogged, slow courts, as well as security and political conditions,” he wrote in an article for the Ahram Online news website.
Despite the remaining challenges, there are signs that investors are responding positively to the reforms. In January, Egypt sold $4 billion of dollar-denominated bonds on international markets, almost double its initial target.
“Every time I attend a discussion one can sense that officials are aware of everything they should be doing,” said an official at a multinational company. (Agence France-Presse)